DANTE IN LIGHT AND SHADOW X 2

This is a photo of Dante in September of 2014 taken during the day (believe it or not!).  The back yard was almost completely shaded by the crab apple and maple trees except for a brilliant spot of light where the sun broke through the canopy of leaves.

 For this version, I used a filter which added some 'soft noise'.  You can see that the photo appears to have some texture.

And in this version, I used the 'Watercolour Pencil' effect, so it looks more like a drawing.

Which one do you like best?